Need to know if all light novels are considered canon? Here is a simple and comprehensive guide about the canonicity of light novels in different storytelling formats. The answer tends to fluctuate for differing series, authors, and franchises.
A Case Study: BLEACH
In some cases, like the BLEACH series, light novels can indeed be canon. BLEACH novels exist as a collaboration between Tite Kubo, the original creator, and other authors. These novelizations cover either the events of the original series or a different timeline. It’s important to note that their canonicity is often debated, except for those explicitly confirmed by Kubo.
Web Novel VS Light Novel
- Web novels are often the starting point of a series before being selected for publishing.
- Light novels are typically a revised and refined version of the corresponding web novels.
- While storylines remain largely similar, changes can occur during the transposition from a web novel to a light novel.
In terms of which is more canon, this usually leans towards light novels as they reflect the final, polished version approved by the author.
Specific Variations
- For example, in the Re:Zero series, the light novel is considered the official canon. This is because the web novel is employed as a draft for future polished versions in printed form.
- In contrast, the My Hero Academia light novels may or may not be canon, depending on the specific content. Some events might contribute to the overall understanding of the series but these novels aren’t necessarily crucial for understanding the plot.
Franchise-Specific Canon Decisions
One thing to keep in mind is the canonicity also depends heavily on the property holders. In some titles, both original author and the publication have a say on what elements are or aren’t canon. While the author’s word is certainly heavily weighted, final decisions often land with the franchise owners.
Conclusions
In a nutshell, it’s difficult to say whether all light novels are canon as it largely depends on the specific series and franchise they are connected with. Some light novels are, indeed, canon, while others serve as additional non-canon content or different storytelling formats.