What is the Essential Formula to Craft a Murder Mystery?

Do you have a hunger to craft a thrilling and captivating murder mystery? Or perhaps your readers are eager for a new, spine-chilling whodunit from your pen? Writing a murder mystery involves certain key elements and an unwritten formula that will help you construct a page-turner.

Establish Your Characters

To begin constructing your eye-catching murder mystery, you must first determine who is who in your story. Start from scratch and create your characters, focusing on the following aspects:

  • What are the backstories of your characters?
  • What motivates them?
  • Which character will become your sleuth, the hero who cracks the case?

Also, consider constructing a character sheet for each primary character to keep track of their traits and backstories.

writer working station

Plot Development

Once you have your characters, center your attention on the main plot. A murder mystery plot should be intriguing and suspenseful that progressively reveals surprising yet plausible events, keeping readers at the edge of their seats. Here’s what you should ponder:

  • What crime took place, and what are the particulars?
  • Who could have a motive to commit such an act?
  • What clues did they leave?

Get into the finer details, and your plot will start to unravel as you navigate through these initial questions.

The Engaging Hook

Begin your story by immediately immersing your readers into the narrative. The beginning or “hook” of your story must be intriguing, enticing your audience and encouraging them to keep reading. Remember, every scene must serve the plot and introduce the characters in a memorable way.

fountain pen

Show, Don’t Tell

An essential rule of writing is to show, don’t tell. Engage your readers by allowing them to participate in the reasoning and deductions. Ensure the readers are always on par with your main character.

If they guess the murderer before your protagonist, they may become bored, while if the detective is too far ahead, they could feel cheated or frustrated.

Constructing a Twist

A successful twist is key to a murder mystery story. An unforeseeable yet plausible twist grips the reader and makes your narrative unforgettable. However, be careful not to make the twist too transparent or obscure.

Ensure you leave in enough clues for your readers to piece together the puzzle.

writing work station


In conclusion, writing a murder mystery involves a blend of character development, plot progression, engagement, revelation, and a shocking twist. When woven together skilfully, this formula will keep your readers’ eyes glued to each word until they turn the last page. Now, you are ready to write your page-turning murder mystery, go and let your imagination run wild!

Related articles

Leave a Comment